');
US City Data

Carthage vs Islandia

Side-by-side comparison

How does Carthage, NY compare to Islandia, NY? Carthage has a population of 3,546 with a median household income of $58,356, while Islandia has 3,581 residents and a median income of $112,435. Below you'll find a detailed breakdown of demographics, economy, and housing for both cities.

Population & Demographics
MetricCarthage, NYIslandia, NYDifference
Population3,5463,581-1.0%
Median Age27.839.1-28.9%
Foreign Born %3.2%39.2%-91.8%
Economy
MetricCarthageIslandiaDifference
Median Income$58,356$112,435-48.1%
Unemployment5.3%3.6%+47.2%
Poverty Rate18.6%3.4%+447.1%
Bachelor's+19%30.8%-38.3%
Housing
MetricCarthageIslandiaDifference
Home Value$126,300$451,700-72.0%
Median Rent$959/mo$1781/mo-46.2%
Housing Units1,6151,324+22.0%

Learn More

Carthage, NY ProfileIslandia, NY ProfileCost of Living in New YorkMore ComparisonsCity Rankings