');
US City Data

Middletown vs Bay Shore

Side-by-side comparison

How does Middletown, NY compare to Bay Shore, NY? Middletown has a population of 30,227 with a median household income of $77,174, while Bay Shore has 31,275 residents and a median income of $101,695. Below you'll find a detailed breakdown of demographics, economy, and housing for both cities.

Population & Demographics
MetricMiddletown, NYBay Shore, NYDifference
Population30,22731,275-3.4%
Median Age35.736-0.8%
Foreign Born %20.2%32.2%-37.3%
Economy
MetricMiddletownBay ShoreDifference
Median Income$77,174$101,695-24.1%
Unemployment6.1%4.1%+48.8%
Poverty Rate15.5%8%+93.8%
Bachelor's+19.8%29.7%-33.3%
Housing
MetricMiddletownBay ShoreDifference
Home Value$271,000$467,800-42.1%
Median Rent$1614/mo$1907/mo-15.4%
Housing Units11,01810,183+8.2%

Learn More

Middletown, NY ProfileBay Shore, NY ProfileCost of Living in New YorkMore ComparisonsCity Rankings